The Saint-Scientist Vallalar has a precise answer for what you came here for, which is is it wrong to eat animals. This question does not usually come from a place of simple curiosity. It often rises from a deep, quiet discomfortβa feeling that something is fundamentally out of balance in how we live. You may be feeling the weight of that question right now, and it is a real weight. Many traditions offer rules or ethical frameworks to answer it. Vallalar, however, approached it not as a moral problem to be solved, but as a matter of spiritual science with direct consequences for the body and soul. To understand his perspective, we need to look at the man who lived it.
The Life and Teachings of Vallalar
Ramalinga Swamigal, known as Vallalar, was a 19th-century Tamil mystic whose collected writings, the Thiru Arutpa, remain one of the most extraordinary spiritual records ever produced. His life was filled with remarkable featsβthough he dismissed anything supernatural, insisting that everything he did was a science. He established a center for feeding the poor that has operated continuously, without interruption, for over 150 years. On January 30, 1874, accounts from those present record that he locked himself in a room in Mettukuppam and was never seen againβhis body never found. This event is documented by government records and by British Collector John Henry Garstin.
So, is it wrong to eat animals according to Vallalar?
Vallalarβs teaching on this is direct. He taught that the suffering we cause to other living souls is not a neutral act. It accumulates as karma that inevitably returns to the one who caused it. This is not a divine punishment from an angry god, but a natural law, as certain as gravity. The fear, pain, and violence inflicted upon an animal become a subtle imprint on the person who consumes it, returning later in the form of physical disease or unseen dangers.
This principle is the core of his teaching on Jeeva Karunyam, or compassion toward all living beings. For Vallalar, this was not just a noble sentiment but the absolute foundation of spiritual progress. He taught that without actively preventing the suffering of others, no amount of prayer, meditation, or ritual could lead to true spiritual realization. The body and soul cannot be purified while they are sustained by violence.
The Overlooked Answer: Godβs Extraordinary Compassion
While the law of karma is absolute, Vallalarβs primary emphasis was not on the consequences of our actions. It was on something far more powerful: the extraordinary and relentless compassion of God, which he called Arut Perum Joti, the Vast Grace-Light.
His most profound insight was this: even while we are actively causing harm to other sentient beings, God continues to sustain us. The sun still shines on us, the air still fills our lungs, and our bodies are still given the energy to live another day. This is not an oversight. It is an act of immense grace. God does not withdraw support when we make a mistake. Instead, we are given another moment, another breath, another chance to see clearly and choose differently.
This constant, unconditional support in the face of our harmful actions is the ultimate proof of a divine compassion that operates beyond our understanding of merit or punishment.
Grace Itself Is the Invitation
For Vallalar, this unending grace was not a license to continue causing harm. It was the invitation to stop. The fact that we are sustained by a compassionate power while acting uncompassionately is the most powerful call to align ourselves with that source. It is a quiet, persistent message: βI am giving you life. Choose to give life, too.β
Responding to this invitation is not about fear of karmic retribution or a sense of guilt. It is a natural response to overwhelming love. When we recognize that we are being held and supported by an infinite compassion, the desire to cause suffering naturally begins to fall away. We begin to practice Jeeva Karunyam not as a rule to be followed, but as an expression of gratitude for the grace we are already receiving.
This shift in perspective changes the question from βIs it wrong?β to βDoes this action align with the grace that sustains me?β
A Daily Practice for Cultivating Compassion
Vallalar did not just provide a philosophy; he provided a practical tool for aligning the self with the divine compassion he spoke of. He gave the world a Mahamantra, a great sound-formula, for this purpose.
AruαΉ Perum JΕti β AruαΉ Perum JΕti β
TaαΉi Perum KaruαΉai β AruαΉ Perum JΕti
The translation is:
The Vast Grace-Light. The Vast Grace-Light.
The Incomparable Great Compassion. The Vast Grace-Light.
Reciting these words, even for a few minutes each day, helps to attune the mind and body to the reality of this grace. It is not a prayer asking for something, but a statement of what is already true. It orients our attention toward the grace that is present in every moment, making it easier to act from a place of compassion rather than habit.
One Small Step Toward Compassionate Living
You do not need to change your entire life overnight. Vallalarβs path is one of gradual, sincere steps.
Here is one concrete action you can take today. The next time you sit down to eat, pause for a moment. Instead of judging the food or yourself, simply hold a quiet question in your mind: βDoes this meal reduce or increase the total suffering in the world?β Do not look for a perfect answer or feel pressured to act. Just hold the question honestly for a few seconds. This simple act of awareness, Vallalar taught, is the beginning of Jeeva Karunyam in action.
You came here for is it wrong to eat animals and found something worth reading. Want much more? The Sanmarkkam Journey delivers free teachings, health guidance, and translations of Vallalarβs works, directly to your inbox. We take you by hand, at your own pace. No pressure, no selling. Just value. Unsubscribe with one click. Join the Sanmarkkam Journey
Want Vallalar's wisdom
delivered free to your inbox?
All directly to your favourite email inbox.
We take you by hand, at your own pace. Step-by-Step.
- Free E-book: Jeevakarunyam Ozhukkam β Vallalar's Guide to Compassionate Living IMMEDIATE DOWNLOAD
- Free E-books, translations & commentaries
- Free health tips from Vallalar's manuscripts
- Free community
- Free Emporium items
- & Much More π
π―οΈ Welcome to the Journey
Look for an email from international@sanmarkkamlife.org. Check your inbox, spam folder and Promotions tab. Your first teaching and your free e-book are on their way.
π We hate Spam. No Pressure. 0 Selling or Pitching.
1 Click Unsubscribe any time.
Privacy Policy Β· Sanmarkkam Life APS Β· GDPR compliant